Bookworm Room

Conservatives deal with facts and reach conclusions; liberals have conclusions and sell them as facts.

  • Easy Ways To Teach Kids
  • Bookworm’s Book
  • Books!
  • Contact Bookworm

The different faces of the military — two SEAL autobiographies

June 11, 2012 by Bookworm 4 Comments

Within the last two weeks, I’ve read two Navy SEAL books:  Marcus Luttrell’s Service: A Navy SEAL at War and Chris Kyle’s American Sniper: The Autobiography of the Most Lethal Sniper in U.S. Military History.

The books have a lot of similarities, separate from the fact that both are books about SEALS seeing service in Iraq during and before the Anbar awakening.  Luttrell and Kyle are both Texas boys (who, unsurprisingly, are friends); they both value the triumvirate of Country, God, and Family, although not necessarily in that order; they both have a superhuman capacity for exertion and suffering, which is a necessity for a SEAL; they both describe the devastating long-term effects on their bodies from constant training and battle, hardships they willingly endure because they love their jobs and their country; and they both are fiercely, almost fanatically devoted to the SEALS.

What’s different about the books, and what makes it worthwhile to read both, is tone.  Despite being a Texas good ol’ boy, Luttrell’s view of the SEALS is almost reverent.  His SEALS don’t come across as choir boys, but they are remarkably close to the PG-rated, family-loving, lite beer-drinking SEALS in Act of Valor. After his Afghanistan ordeal, Luttrell’s subsequent service in Iraq comes close to a martyrdom, as he struggles against debilitating physical injury in order to be out there with his Teams.

Kyle adores the SEALs, but has no reverence.  These are hard charging men who drink, brawl, and haze each other with cheerful, impartial brutality.  When they’re off duty, and have nothing else to do, they play computer games and watch porn.  These are the R-rated SEALS.  These are men who naturally have testosterone infusing their testosterone.  I have a suspicion that they’re closer to the real deal than are Luttrell’s SEALS, who seem to have come out of central casting, circa the John Wayne era.  Kyle clearly loves war.  He’s no sadist, but there is pleasure for him in defeating an enemy he describes as “savage” and “barbarian.”

I’ve been wondering about the different approach these two men take to describing their comrades.  Are Luttrell and Kyle so different in personality that they simply see their team members through a different filter?  Or are they writing for very different audiences?  Luttrell gained national prominence because of his experiences in Afghanistan, whereas Kyle may be more of a military phenomenon.  This means that Luttrell has to appeal to — and is selling the SEALS to — a broader spectrum of Americans than Kyle.

The books are a perfectly matched set (and you know how I love my matched sets), so I recommend reading both.  Combining Luttrell’s more cerebral approach with Kyle’s earthier stories gives a well-rounded view of the brave and slightly insane (in a very good way) men who willingly engage in uncomfortable, brutal, and dangerous warfare so that the majority of Americans can live out their lives in comfort and safety.  I have inordinate admiration for these men, but I do get the feeling that you have to be as tough as they are to function around them.

Also, both books offer a good insight into the chasm between actual fighting in the field, and the political fighting at home that so often handicapped them.  Frustration is the name-of-the-game for front line fighters who have the enemy in their sights and are constrained by almost arbitrary rules of engagement.  The theory behind the rules of engagement is to leave a loving population behind.  But war is not loving, and things would probably have gone better if the government had trusted the troops a little more, and allowed them to wage a quick, clean-ish war, rather than a slow, enervating war.

Filed Under: Books, Military Tagged With: American Sniper: The Autobiography of the Most Lethal Sniper in U.S. Military History, Chris Kyle, Iraq, Marcus Luttrell, Navy SEALS, Service a Navy Seal at War, War

I’m getting ready for Memorial Day by reading Marcus Luttrell’s Service : A Navy Seal At War

May 21, 2012 by Bookworm 2 Comments

I got myself a copy of Marcus Luttrell’s Service: A Navy SEAL at War, which I am very much looking forward to reading. I loved his Lone Survivor: The Eyewitness Account of Operation Redwing and the Lost Heroes of SEAL Team 10, even though it made me cry — which is not something I usually look for in a book.

In his first book, written with Patrick Robinson, Luttrell came across as an extremely appealing character — patriotic, insanely committed to the service, humble, funny, and a little bit snarky. In his most recent book, Luttrell is getting help from James D. Hornfischer. I hope that I get to hear the same “Luttrell” voice in my head. I’ll keep you guys posted.

Filed Under: Military Tagged With: Lone Survivor, Marcus Luttrell, Service a Navy Seal at War

Writing this blog is a labor of love. However, if you'd like to donate money for my efforts, please feel free to do so:

Top Posts & Pages

  • American colleges -- the un-educating of young America
  • Viral photos showing Paris in its death throes
  • Please don't feed the troll
  • [VIDEO] Scott Adams: fake news relies on our imperfect knowledge
  • [VIDEO] All theories about our universe are matters of faith

Recent Comments

  • NeoWayland on [VIDEOS] Mothering blacks to death and cops are the good guys
  • NRA4Life on [VIDEOS] Mothering blacks to death and cops are the good guys
  • Tonestaple on RIP, Barbara Bush
  • NeoWayland on [VIDEOS] Mothering blacks to death and cops are the good guys
  • NeoWayland on [VIDEOS] Mothering blacks to death and cops are the good guys

The Watcher’s Council

  • Ask Marion
  • Bookworm Room
  • The Daley Gator
  • Don Surber
  • The Glittering Eye
  • Fausta's Blog
  • GrEaT sAtAn"S gIrLfRiEnD
  • The Independent Sentinel
  • JoshuaPundit
  • Maggie's Notebook
  • New Zeal
  • Nice Deb
  • The Noisy Room
  • Politically Short
  • Puma By Design
  • The Razor
  • The Right Planet
  • Virginia Right!
  • Watcher Of Weasels
Although this is a WordPress blog, it's on a dedicated server. This means that, if you have a WordPress.com ID, it will not work here. To leave comments at Bookworm Room, please register here.

Pages

  • Books!
  • Bookworm’s Books
  • Contact Bookworm
  • Easy Ways To Teach Kids
  • Fighting Keyboardists

Archives

Categories

  • 9/11
  • Abortion
  • Activism
  • Afghanistan
  • Africa
  • African-Americans
  • America
  • Animal rights
  • Anti-Americanism
  • Anti-Semitism
  • Arabs
  • Argentina
  • Art
  • Australia
  • Barack Obama
  • BBC
  • Bill Clinton
  • Bits and Pieces
  • Blogfriends
  • Blogs and Blogging
  • Books
  • Britain
  • Bureaucracy
  • California
  • Canada
  • Capitalism
  • Carly Fiorina
  • Children
  • China
  • Chris Christie
  • Christians
  • Civil War
  • Climate change
  • College Course Catalogs
  • Communism
  • Congress
  • Conservative ideology
  • Constitution
  • Corruption
  • Crime and punishment
  • Cuba
  • Cuba
  • Culture
  • Death penalty
  • Democrats
  • Denmark
  • Donald Trump
  • Ebola
  • Economics
  • Education
  • Egypt
  • Elections
  • Energy
  • England
  • Environmentalism
  • Europe
  • Euthanasia
  • Feminism
  • France
  • Free speech
  • Freedom
  • Gay marriage
  • GBLT
  • Gender
  • George Soros
  • Germany
  • Germany
  • Government
  • Greece
  • Hamas
  • Health
  • Hezbollah
  • Hillary Clinton
  • Holland
  • Hollywood
  • Holocaust
  • Homosexuality
  • Identity politics
  • Illustrated editions
  • Immigration
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • ISIS
  • Islam
  • Islamic State/ISIS
  • Israel
  • Japan
  • Jews
  • Jihad
  • Jimmy Carter
  • John McCain
  • Jordan
  • Judges
  • Judicial activism
  • Just Because Music
  • Law
  • Lefties on Parade
  • Leftist morality
  • Liberal Fascism
  • Libertarianism
  • Libya
  • Marin County
  • Marriage
  • Media matters
  • Men
  • Mexico
  • Mike Huckabee
  • Military
  • Morality
  • Multiculturalism
  • Muslim violence
  • National Security
  • Nazis
  • Newt Gingrich
  • North Korea
  • Norway
  • Open Threads
  • Pakistan
  • Palestinians
  • Parenting
  • personal responsibility
  • Police
  • Political correctness
  • Politics
  • Presidential elections
  • Race
  • Rand Paul
  • Religion
  • Republicans
  • Revolutionary War
  • Rick Perry
  • Russia
  • San Francisco
  • Sarah Palin
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Science
  • Second Amendment
  • Self-reliance
  • Semantics
  • Sex
  • Silly Stuff
  • Socialism
  • South Africa
  • Strict constructionism
  • Sweden
  • Syria
  • Taxes
  • Tea Parties
  • Ted Cruz
  • Tipping Points
  • Truth
  • Tunisia
  • Turkey
  • Unions
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United Nations
  • Uplifting stories
  • Venezuela
  • Vietnam
  • War crimes
  • Watcher of Weasels
  • Welfare
  • White House
  • Women
  • World War II

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2018 · Bookworm Pro News Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in